Posted: February 6th, 2023
Question 2 – Connect: Base your answer to this question on the two assigned readings within the lesson – the interview with a Yale Professor and the blog on Hawaiian Food. (Note: Hawaii itself is part of the U.S.)
What did Freedman mean by when he said there are “three characterizes of American cuisine” are “regionalism, standardization, and variety”? How did each change over time? Does Hawaiian cuisine, as discussed in the PBS article, go along with Freedman’s definition of American cuisine? Explain your answer.
Requirements:
Formatting: 12-point font, Times New Roman, double-spaced, one-inch margins. Points will be deducted if not formatted correctly.
File format: Submit as either a .doc, .docx., or .pdf. Avoid “Shared” documents since they also do not work with the Blackboard system. The assignment will earn a zero if not submitted in the correct format.
Length: Two paragraphs for the section. Each paragraph should be at least six sentences long. Points will be deducted if sentences appear to have been intentionally shortened to meet the required number of sentences.
Editing: Be sure to proofread your answer and use spellcheck before submitting. Points will be deducted for not doing so.
Plagiarism: Plagiarism of any kind will result in automatic failure. Use of outside sources counts as plagiarism.
American Nation, American Empire Sway Lesson
Note: This Sway lesson contains links to additional required readings. As you go through the lesson,
be sure click on the relevant links to read the sections in Yawp, the interview with the Yale Historian
on food history, and the blog on Hawaiian food. If you have any questions, let your professor know.
The American Nation-State & Imperialism
The Civil War (1860-1865) challenged the idea of a single American nation-state at the same time
that the idea of modern nationalism (the alignment of the nation with the state) was popular across
the Atlantic. The Union’s win in the Civil War helped to create a single nation-state (although by
force). To be clear, let’s go over what nation and state mean. The nation is a people or an imagined
community. It is larger than a city or region. A state is a political entity – a government with borders
that is sovereign. The idea of a nation-state is that a people have their own sovereign country. After
the Civil War, people started to use The United States (instead of These United States) more often.
Once they did – once they thought of the United States as a nation-state – then people began to debate
exactly who was part of the American nation. American national identity is based around the
founding ideals such as the right to self rule (democracy), liberty (individual rights), and equality.
The cartoon below, School Begins, was created in 1899, just after the Spanish-American War and
during the Filipino-American War. These imperialist wars sparked a debate over who America was –
was it okay for a nation that had fought for independence from Britain to hold other nations as
colonies? Was it okay to proclaim liberty and self-rule while forcing rule on weaker nations? The first
part of this lesson focuses on U.S. imperialism with regard to Hawaii and the former Spanish
colonies gained through the Spanish-American War.
In the late 19th and early 20th centuries the United States joined the other imperialist powers in
nation-state competition over territory. The U.S. annexation of Hawaii and its victory against Spain
in the Spanish-American War prompted a debate within the U.S. over the meaning of liberty and
American democracy. Read American Yawp Chapter 19, parts II, III, and IV ( Click Here to access
the Yawp Chapter). And, watch the U.S. History Crash Course on Imperialism, just below. Click
Here for the transcript.
School Begins:
Next, look at the School Begins cartoon – what message is the artist trying to display? What do the
different scenes represent? The information in Yawp and the Crash Course should help you decipher
the reason that “Uncle Sam” (representing U.S. policy) is “instructing” the 4 children in the front. The
other images in the cartoon help the artist make his point. See the explanation and evidence below to
help decipher the cartoon.
The political cartoon above, School Begins, appeared in Puck magazine in January, 1899. The center
of the cartoon is Uncle Sam “teaching” four frightened children, who are symbolic of the U.S.’s
newly acquired territories, about the “ First Lessons in Self Government,” as the book on his desk
suggests. The cartoonist, Dalrymple, was being satirical. His cartoon was a critique of U.S.
imperialism and the U.S. rhetoric that went along with imperialism. Pro-imperialists argued that they
were not taking over other territories for financial gain or other selfish reasons. Instead, they claimed,
they were spreading civilization and democracy.
Dalrymple’s cartoon sought to highlight the hypocrisy of imperialists’ claims to be spreading
democracy and civilization by including the image of a blackboard with the following scribble across
it: “The consent of the governed is a good thing in theory, but very rare in fact. — England has
governed her colonies whether they consented or not. By not waiting for their consent she has greatly
advanced the world’s civilization. — The U.S. must govern its new territories with or without their
consent until they can govern themselves.” To Dalrymple, and other critics of U.S. imperialism, he
viewed U.S. imperialist actions as counter to the ideals of the U.S., namely self-government.
The first part of this lesson provided an introduction to the rise of the American empire, with a focus
on the annexation of Hawaii and the Spanish-American War, which will provide the historical
context for the image of the four “children” in the front of the image. The scenes in the background
of the cartoon – the black child washing the window, the Native American child next to the door, and
the Chinese boy standing outside – represent other aspects of U.S. domestic and foreign policy. By
including these other scenes, Dalrymple is trying to drive home his point. Let’s look at the other
images to help us decipher Dalrymple’s message.
SOLUTION
Jonathan Freedman, a cultural critic, argued that there are three main characteristics of American cuisine: regionalism, standardization, and variety.
Regionalism refers to the unique food traditions and ingredients that are specific to different regions within the United States. This includes dishes like New England clam chowder and Southern fried chicken.
Standardization refers to the way that certain dishes have become popular and widely recognized across the country, such as hamburgers and hot dogs.
Variety refers to the wide range of food options available to Americans, including cuisines from different countries and ethnic groups.
Over time, these characteristics have evolved. For example, regionalism has become more prominent as people have become more interested in local and sustainable food sources. Standardization has also changed as chain restaurants have become more common and have standardized their menu offerings. Variety has increased with the rise of globalization and immigration, leading to a wider range of international cuisines available in the United States.
Hawaiian cuisine, as discussed in the PBS article, aligns with Freedman’s definition of American cuisine in terms of variety. Hawaiian cuisine is a fusion of traditional Polynesian cooking techniques and flavors with American, Chinese, Japanese, and Filipino ingredients and cooking styles. This reflects the diversity and variety of food traditions that are found in the United States.
Place an order in 3 easy steps. Takes less than 5 mins.